Wolf Law is proud to serve Denver and surrounding communities, helping people understand what to expect at every stage of a Colorado criminal case. For someone who has pleaded guilty, accepted a plea agreement, or been convicted at trial, the sentencing hearing is one of the most important court appearances in the entire process. It is when the judge determines the consequences that will follow the conviction.
A Colorado sentencing hearing can involve much more than simply announcing jail time or probation. Depending on the case, the judge may review a presentence report, hear arguments from prosecutors and defense counsel, consider statements from victims, review mitigating evidence, hear directly from the defendant, and decide among the sentencing options permitted by Colorado law.
Knowing what to expect can make the process less uncertain and help defendants prepare effectively. In Denver, Aurora, Lakewood, and throughout Colorado, careful sentencing preparation can be a critical part of an overall criminal defense strategy.
What Is a Sentencing Hearing in Colorado?
A sentencing hearing occurs after a defendant has been found guilty or entered a guilty plea. At that hearing, the judge determines what sentence should be imposed within the boundaries established by Colorado law.
Sentencing may happen immediately after a plea or conviction in some cases, while other cases require a separate hearing at a later date. More serious matters often involve additional preparation before sentencing, including a presentence investigation.
Under Colorado Rule of Criminal Procedure 32, sentence must be imposed without unreasonable delay. Before imposing the sentence, the judge must give the defendant an opportunity to speak and present information in mitigation. The prosecution must also have an opportunity to address matters relevant to sentencing.
The sentencing options available depend heavily on the offense. They can include probation, county jail, imprisonment, community-based alternatives where legally available, fines, restitution, treatment requirements, and other conditions.
A sentencing hearing therefore should not be treated as a formality. The information placed before the judge can affect decisions with significant consequences for a defendant’s freedom and future.
What Happens Before a Colorado Sentencing Hearing?
The period between conviction and sentencing can involve substantial preparation.
In many felony cases, a probation officer prepares a presentence investigation and written report before the court imposes sentence. Under Colorado Rule of Criminal Procedure 32, a report generally is required when a defendant is being sentenced for a felony and the judge has discretion regarding punishment. A judge can also order one in a misdemeanor case.
The presentence investigation may collect information about the defendant’s history and circumstances and evaluate available sentencing options. Defense counsel and the prosecution generally receive the report before the hearing, giving the parties an opportunity to review it.
Before sentencing, our preparation may include:
- Reviewing the Presentence Report: We examine the report for factual errors, misleading statements, or information that requires additional explanation.
- Gathering Mitigation: Employment records, treatment documentation, educational records, character letters, and other evidence may help show rehabilitation and stability.
- Evaluating Sentencing Law: We determine what penalties are legally available and whether mandatory sentencing provisions or other restrictions apply.
- Preparing the Defendant: We discuss what to expect in court and whether the defendant should make a statement.
- Developing a Sentencing Argument: We identify the lawful sentence we believe is appropriate and organize the evidence supporting that position.
Preparation should begin well before the hearing itself.
What Is a Presentence Investigation Report?
A presentence investigation report, sometimes called a PSI or presentence report, gives the judge information beyond the basic facts of the conviction.
Colorado Rule of Criminal Procedure 32 provides that when a presentence investigation is required, the probation officer prepares a written report before sentencing. The report is provided to the prosecution and defense in advance of the hearing. Under the rule, copies ordinarily must be provided at least 72 hours before sentencing, although a party may request earlier delivery under specified procedures.
A report may address matters such as the defendant’s background, criminal record, employment, education, family situation, and sentencing alternatives. It may also contain recommendations concerning probation.
Defense attorneys should review this material carefully. A mistake in a presentence report should not simply be ignored because a judge may rely on the document when deciding a sentence.
For example, if a report incorrectly describes a prior case, fails to reflect completed treatment, or omits relevant information about a defendant’s circumstances, we may raise those issues before sentencing.
If you have a sentencing hearing approaching, call Wolf Law at 720.479.8574 for a free consultation. We can review the stage of your case and help you understand what preparation may be appropriate.
What Happens During the Sentencing Hearing?
Although each case is different, sentencing hearings generally follow a recognizable structure.
The judge first confirms the case and addresses any preliminary issues. The court may discuss the presentence report, applicable plea agreement, sentencing range, restitution, or disagreements that need to be resolved.
The prosecution then has an opportunity to present its sentencing position. Depending on the case, prosecutors may discuss the seriousness of the offense, prior record, impact of the conduct, aggravating circumstances, and the sentence they believe should be imposed.
Defense counsel can then present arguments supporting a different outcome. This may include mitigating evidence, testimony, letters, treatment records, rehabilitation efforts, employment information, or other facts relevant to sentencing.
Colorado Rule of Criminal Procedure 32 specifically requires the court to provide the defendant an opportunity to make a statement before sentence is imposed.
After considering the information presented, the judge announces the sentence and explains the court’s orders.
Can the Defendant Speak at a Colorado Sentencing Hearing?
Yes. A defendant has an opportunity to address the judge before the sentence is imposed. This is commonly referred to as allocution.
Allocution can give a defendant an opportunity to express remorse, accept responsibility, explain personal circumstances, discuss rehabilitation, or tell the court what they plan to do differently moving forward.
That does not mean every defendant should simply speak spontaneously.
A poorly considered statement can undermine other sentencing arguments. For example, a defendant who appears to blame everyone else, minimize serious conduct, contradict established facts, or make statements inconsistent with the defense strategy can create additional problems.
Before sentencing, we discuss whether a statement is appropriate and what issues a client should consider addressing.
A useful statement may focus on:
- Accountability: Acknowledging conduct appropriately when doing so is consistent with the legal posture of the case.
- Rehabilitation: Explaining meaningful steps already taken, such as treatment, counseling, education, or sobriety.
- Impact: Demonstrating an understanding that the conduct affected other people.
- Future Plans: Providing specific information about employment, family responsibilities, treatment, or other plans.
- Respect for the Court: Speaking sincerely and directly without arguing with the judge or prosecution.
There is no universal script. The best approach depends on the individual case.
Do Victims Get to Speak at Sentencing in Colorado?
In qualifying cases, victims have rights related to the sentencing process, including opportunities to provide information concerning the impact of the offense.
Colorado’s victim-rights framework provides for victim impact statements and notification concerning sentencing or resentencing hearings in covered cases.
A victim’s statement can address issues such as emotional, financial, or other effects of the offense and may be considered by the judge when determining an appropriate sentence.
For defendants, this can make sentencing emotionally difficult. It is important to remain composed and respectful during the proceeding, even when statements contain allegations or descriptions the defendant disputes.
Defense counsel can address appropriate factual or legal issues through proper argument rather than allowing the hearing to become a direct confrontation.
How Does a Judge Decide the Sentence?
Colorado judges must operate within the sentencing laws applicable to the particular conviction. Within those legal boundaries, several factors may affect the final decision.
The court may consider:
- Seriousness of the Offense: The underlying conduct and consequences can significantly influence sentencing.
- Criminal History: Prior convictions and previous performance on probation or other sentences may be relevant.
- Mitigating Circumstances: Rehabilitation, treatment, employment, family responsibilities, limited prior history, and circumstances surrounding the offense may support a more favorable sentence.
- Aggravating Circumstances: Certain facts may support a more severe sentence when permitted by law.
- Presentence Information: The judge may consider the information and recommendations contained in a presentence investigation.
- Arguments From Both Sides: Prosecutors and defense attorneys can each explain why a particular sentence is appropriate.
- Statements From the Defendant and Victims: The court may consider information presented directly during the hearing.
Different offenses also operate under different sentencing structures. Colorado has two misdemeanor classes, while drug offenses use a separate classification system rather than simply following standard felony classifications.
An individual facing sentencing should therefore avoid assuming that the sentence imposed in another person’s case predicts what will happen in theirs.
Can You Get Probation Instead of Jail at Sentencing?
Sometimes, but probation is not available or appropriate in every case.
Whether probation is legally possible depends on the conviction, applicable statutes, criminal history, plea agreement, and other circumstances. If probation is available, a judge may consider whether the person can be safely supervised in the community and whether conditions such as treatment, testing, classes, community service, or other requirements are appropriate.
Someone sentenced to probation must follow the conditions ordered by the court. Colorado Judicial Branch guidance explains that failure to comply with probation conditions may result in a complaint and hearing. If probation is revoked, an adult defendant may potentially face resentencing that could include probation, community corrections, jail, or prison where legally authorized.
This makes it important to think about sentencing beyond simply avoiding immediate incarceration. The conditions imposed can affect a defendant’s daily life for months or years.
Wolf Law can help evaluate the realistic sentencing options in your case. Contact us at 720.479.8574 for a free consultation before your hearing.
Why Sentencing Preparation Matters
Consider a defendant in Aurora who is awaiting sentencing after a DUI conviction. If that individual has voluntarily completed treatment, remained sober, complied with court orders, maintained employment, and gathered documentation showing those efforts, the court will have more information available than it would from the conviction alone.
A person facing an assault sentence in Denver might similarly present counseling records, character letters, employment history, or evidence concerning the particular circumstances of the incident.
In Lakewood, someone appearing for sentencing at the Jefferson County Courthouse may have only one opportunity to make sure important mitigating information is placed before the judge.
None of these facts guarantee a particular outcome. They can, however, help the court evaluate the defendant as an individual rather than relying solely on the charging documents or criminal history.
That is why we treat sentencing as its own stage of defense strategy.
Wolf Law represents individuals throughout Colorado with a criminal defense focus centered on preparation and strong advocacy. Attorneys and Partners Jeff Wolf and Colleen Kelley lead our defense team, and both bring decades of trial experience, rigorous preparation, and sharp legal analysis to the full range of our criminal defense practice. Both attorneys are known for their national media presence on Court TV and Law & Crime, and both handle DUI and DWAI, domestic violence, assault and violent crimes, drug charges, theft, probation violations, and other criminal matters. Our collaborative philosophy is built around careful preparation and helping clients understand every stage of the process, from the initial accusation through sentencing and beyond.
What Happens Immediately After the Judge Announces the Sentence?
Once the judge imposes sentence, the defendant must comply with the court’s orders.
If probation is imposed, the defendant will generally receive instructions concerning supervision and the conditions that must be completed. Colorado Judicial Branch guidance notes that a person placed on supervised probation will work with a probation officer to satisfy the terms established by the court.
If incarceration is ordered, the timing and process for entering custody can depend on the case and the judge’s order.
The judgment may also address restitution, fines, costs, credit for qualifying presentence confinement, and other legally required matters. Colorado Rule of Criminal Procedure 32 provides that the judgment of conviction includes the sentence and specified findings concerning matters such as presentence confinement and restitution.
A defendant should leave court understanding exactly what is required. Missing reporting deadlines or misunderstanding sentencing conditions can create additional legal problems.
Contact Wolf Law Before Your Colorado Sentencing Hearing
A sentencing hearing can have immediate and long-term consequences for your freedom, employment, family, finances, and future. The judge may have important decisions to make, and the defense should be prepared to give the court accurate, persuasive, and legally relevant information before those decisions are made.
Wolf Law represents clients facing criminal charges and sentencing throughout Denver, Aurora, Lakewood, and surrounding Colorado communities. If your sentencing hearing is approaching, call Wolf Law at 720.479.8574 for a free consultation. We can help you understand what to expect, identify relevant mitigating information, and prepare for one of the most consequential stages of your criminal case.